राज्य मा धर्म लाग्नु पर्छ भन्ने मलाइ लाग्दैन, तर यो facebook आदिमा लेखेको तर्क हरु देख्दा चै दिक्क लाग्छ. आआ हिन्दु धर्म नै गर्दे पनि ठिकै हो जस्तो लाग्छ.

१. पहिचान पहिचान को नारा लागेको छ. मौलिक भाषा, मौलिक चलनको अधिकारको बारेमा हल्ला चलेको छ. तर थुप्रैको लागि धर्मनै पहिचान हो. धर्मको नाउमा राज्य कोर्ने कि? धर्मलाइ चै अरु चलनको जस्तो मौलिक अधिकार किन नपाउने?

२. ड्राफ्ट संविधान पछि, गाउँ गाउँ मा गएर जनता हरुको राय बुझियो. दुइ दिन छुटी दिएर जनताको सुझाव लियियो. कुन अधारमा त्यो सुझावको अवलम्बन गर्ने? प्रजातन्त्र मा बहुमतको राय मान्नु पर्ने हैन? Referendum गरिनु पर्ने हैन? Referendum गरे हिन्दु धर्मले नै बहुमत पाउँछ भनेर हो कि? बहुमतको हिसाबले हिन्दु राष्ट्र हुनु पर्ने हो, बहुमत नभए के को अधार लिने त?

हिन्दु राष्ट्र बनाउनु भनेको अरु धर्मले बस्न नपाउने हैन. लिम्बुवान भन्दैमा किरातले बस्न नपाउने हैन, भन्या जस्तै हो. हो, धर्म परिवर्तन गर्न चै कानुन ले रोक लगाउँछ.

सबैको फुल्बारिलाई एउटा धर्मको राष्ट्र नबनाउ भन्छन. के हुन्छ बनाए? कुनै सहि तर्क देखिन अहिलेसम्म.

ok i need Christian rastra, will u let me have it?

I am against it. I grew up as a Hindu, now an atheist, living overseas. I love and respect all religions. Our Nepali Hindu will eventually be at a disadvantage since this is India trying to flex its muscle by forcing some people to believe it is to our advantage. Remember, India has a huge interest in our land and resources. They will be as disaster like they came to help during the earthquake. If Nepali does become a Hindu state, you are officially handing our country to India just like Sikkim. You will slowly become a state of India. If you think India controls and intervene too much in our politics now, just imagine what will happen after this. So be careful of what you wish for. 

m*j* pakhandi haru

Hindu rastra = Lick my B@lls

काले पिले जुंगे इन्डियन ले बाबाजी के "प्रसाद" है भन्दै .... " हिन्दु राष्ट्र" चाहिए भन्दै हिड्ने, युजली टोआ मोड मे नजर आने वाले, आनसासपेकटिंग च्याखुरे नेपाली बाहुन** लोग के चाक पद्काने का प्लान है/ हाम्रे गाव मे ऐसा भिक्टिम बहुत हो गया है /आब जब कोइ भी "हिन्दु राष्ट्र" के नाम सुनते हि पिचुवाड़े पकड़के भाग्ने लग ते है//

" हिन्दु राष्ट्र" चाहिए भन्दै हिड्ने, युजली टोआ मोड मे नजर आने वाले, आनसासपेकटिंग च्याखुरे नेपाली बाहुन** लोग हो हो हो होसियार!!!!!PUBLIC SERVICE ANNOUNCEMENT!!!!

fuck hindu rastra! I hate Nepali/Indian religion/culture.

https://www.facebook.com/video.php?v=491434147697440

Kiddo this guy has the best answer why Hindu tag should not be removed. I don't know if you can open the link but Kumar Regmi the senior lawyer speak for the people.

There in-lies the problem. I just haven't seen legitimate argument against having a hindu=rashtra, other than the opinion (which I align with) that religion and governance should be kept separate.

@divorceguy. Not sure you are just trolling but if that's your argument then it is not much different than a small group of people claiming the state for themselves. Well, who decides who gets what? Should it be left for the referendum? If we go with "democracy" then the majority should get their say, in which case it no-doubtedly becomes hindurashtra, and your "Christian rastra" point will be voided.

@Vhotee. While I agree with your secular sentiments, I don't share the apprehension of India taking over if we become Hindu rashtra. First of all, India itself is not Hindu; it has a major muslim population (largest one next to Indonesia) and a fair share of Christians. Sure, Bhajapa and Shiv Sena might apply the pressure but I just don't see them taking over Nepal, just because Nepal becomes a Hindu rashtra. The fear you have about being Hindu-rashtra is the fear I share of not being one. I will be elated if no religion meddles the politics, but I am afraid that will not be the case. Percentage of Christians in Nepal has taken a geometric progression and has simply exploded. The interest groups working in behalf of Christianity and Islam will be able to openly increase their pressure and frankly speaking, I would pick the liberal Hinduism (or Buddhism) over those religions.

Heck, I am up for making us a Budhist country, that might promote our tourism as well.

Mangale, I didn't click the link but I did listen to one of the lawyer advocating for Hindu rashtra. One point I didn't agree about was his point on religious tourism. If we become a Hindu country, we will attract few more hindus, but will alienate many other religions - including Buddhism.

Invading Nepal in the 21st century is very unlikely regardless of what it ends up being as a nation. If that ever happens, India will receive a massive outcry from the world because Nepal seems to be loved by many countries and India would be another victim of Western power's bomb showers which I don't think those curry smelling head bobbling mofos want to endure.

^ Yep, the same wrath that Russia endured when they annexed Crimea.

jatiya pahichan kojdaa chai bahun haru namanne ani dharmik pahichan chaine re. gadha murkha haru.
hindu rastra ta mandai mandainau.

@Kiddo,

Vhotee
While I agree with your argument on theory, the reality I have seen is much different.

I am not a religious person, but I go to temple and sometimes church for peace of mind. I don't dislike Christianity or any other religion. The issue I am having is the conversion that's being done - not because I am worried about Hinduism becoming extinct, but the way conversions have been taking place in Nepal. Most of the times, the poor and uneducated are promised of a miraculous cure or something else in return. I absolutely detaste the idea of trying to convert somebody else to your religion, voluntarily or forcefully. A person should take his/her own initiative and if he/she likes to convert, he/she should be able to. But many NGOs, diplomats and foreign forces are hell bent on converting Nepalis and there might be bigger motive behind the conversion.

As ridiculous and over the top Nas' claim sound, sometimes there are truth to them. My question is what determines the best path for an issue of contention? Is it the majority or something else? If majority, Hindus will easily out number any other group. The fact that most are quiet, shouldn't be taken as their weakness.

Vhootee

You said "I highly doubt they can go beyond the poor villages in Nepal. Our belief is old and deep rooted."

That is not impossible because that's exactly how the Maoists did it.

Kiddo,

अब काले पिले जुंगे इन्डियन ले बाबाजी के "प्रसाद" है ले लो भन्दै "हिन्दु राष्ट्र" चाहिने च्याखुरे छेत्री बाहुन लडका लड्की को चाक पड्काउने हाम्लाई लाईर ह /

I am Hindu but I don't need my country named specific as "Hindu Nation" .

I am a Hindu, but I am not a gandu! Lol

Nepal should have an Atheist campaign to rid Nepal of all the poison named religion. Religion is a bunch of bull meant to brainwash people. Please are animals like sheep they will follow the herd. They are always looking for someone to follow so they fall into the trap of religion easily which have been followed of hundreds of years.

Atheists should rise up and take leadership to rid the world of all the bs.