Why we need Nepal as a Hindu country?

• In Nepal, Hindu religion has never influenced the legal system like in Christianity or in Islam; it is more a ritual practice which doesn't impose others to follow the same. No fundamentalism was ever get encouraged in Nepal. It remained Sanatan Dharma.
  

• No rules from Dharmashastra as in Islam have ever come into force.
  

• If you see UK, USA and many other developed countries, they revere their religion (Christianity) in national level (see US constitution).They take oath of Bible while getting into office. But have you seen anyone in Nepal taking oath of Gita? It is such a liberal practice in Nepal: it could have been made taking into account that there are multi-ethnic, religious people in Nepal.
  

• Hinduism as practice in India and Nepal are different. Nepal's is much unique that accommodates all. In Nepal, it is ritual based, not a doctrine based. The Gurung, Magar, Rai and other communities who are said to be non-Hindu Janajatis also celebrate Dashain but not as a compulsion. But do they celebrate Id-Ul-Fitra just because they are living in Arghakhachi or Nepalgunj? or can Muslims celebrate Dashain as Gurungs do? If anyone questions: Rai and Limbus celebrate Dashain because of Hindu's pressure, thats never the case in Nepal. Is any Newar Buddist barred from visiting Pashupatinath? whereas a Muslim is barred or a Christian is barred, because without doing so, they could not be controlled in the wave of proselytizing in the past. My point is Nepal's Hindu practice is ritual based, not a doctrine based.
  

• As we see, the Hindu population in Nepal is decreasing due to Christianity they have missionaries to change religion, but do we ever think to change other's religion? Have you ever done that? But ask a Muslim and you will get answer about how many non-Muslims has s/he already converted into Muslim. same in Christianity.
  

• Early in its history, in the absence of other competing religions, Hindus considered everyone they came across as Hindus (Sanathan Dharm) and expected everyone they met to be Hindus. Hindus have never done business of religion. Hindu view of religious freedom is not based on the freedom to proselytize, but the right to retain one’s religion and not be subject to proselyzation. Don't we have the right to protect our religion from being proselytized?

• since we don't believe on conversion of other's religion but others (such as Muslims and Christians) do and they are financially better off, we are always vulnerable to sell our faith (as is seen in remote villages of Nepal), Should a state do justice to Hindus who are 83% in protecting their religion or should it be a witness to a rampant annihilation upon Hindus by Christians in the name of religious freedom and secularism?

• If Hindus were intolerant and suppressive of other minorities of Nepal, how could Muslims in Kathmandu remain safe and secured, up keeping their religious freedom in the heartland of Hindus for more than 200 or so years? If Hindus were suppressive, they could have swept Muslims' identity into dust. Did they do that? And again, it is not wise to compare the Hindu Muslim politics of India with Nepal. Nepal's is an exemplary case of religious harmony which was possible due to its being a Sanatan Hindu state.
  

L.
Georgia State
Atlanta

too much discrimination and abuse of power have taken place in the name of religion. I wish they have served country and people while they are in that kursi. Unfortunately, they did not. We declared secular state in jan andolan 2 and nothing gonna change that. So learn to live with that. This is a new Nepal. lets be nepali first and then religious in person second.

Jana Aandolan 2 never spoke against Hindu religion. It all happened haphazardly due to those mo..f...leaders. Lets not relate Hindu religion with the deeds of brother-killer Gyane, nor is he the incarnation of Lord Vishnu. If it were any incarnation, it could be upto King Birendra's dynasty, because he was a king indeed. I agree with Jhareko Paat that Nepal should remain a Hindu state but that should not reflect in the level of maintaining law and order of the government. Government and religion are different, and it has been different in Nepal for a long time. Unlike the Muslim Shariya law, no dictats of Dharmashastra have been the basis of government laws and constitution in Nepal. Why those mo..f ..u leaders so hurriedly declare Nepal a secular state all of a sudden whereas it was not a prrimary agenda of the Janaaandolan? Its a matter of research. Who was behind this? Possibly a great sum of amount to Maoist-foggers by the Christians? Christian missionaries always want Nepal a secular state so that they could play, just like now. Why the hell such a spectacularly important issue passed so easily and people didn't protest, who used to standstill Nepal against Rhtic Roshan and Madhuri Dixit? It is surprising. I don't blame Nepali people who often a time be the witness of terrible decisions and adhere those. It is because of their illiteracy and consequent disinterestedness. But when they really know these hidden intentions and consequences of wider ramifying decisions, they will come up to the street against these Maoist and other anti-religious elements and missionaries. LETS     GET     UNITED FOR     HINDUISM!!!!

That's the problem. Designating one religion gives too much opportunity to one group. As it always turns out, that person/group abuses power at the expense of others. Castism, discrimation and inequality are the byproducts of power of one person/group. Instead declaring secularism gives equal footing to everyone and promotes peace and equal opportunity.  I believe it is time we all move forward as a Nepali and build better Nepal. Whether physically, mentally or financially, everyone has suffered enough.

Yesterday is history...Naya Nepal is what we need to look forwad to.

sarkozy,
mula "ghanta" ko lets get united? BEEF burger khayera motayeko baun moro! btw I am hindu also but I do eat beef. You should be given choice of animal you can eat, no discrimination on animals based on the species. If you see worldwide only dictator nations are afraid of making their country secular. Peace.
 

191karma,

I understand what you mean but you know the problem is there: making Nepal a secular is jeaopardy to our culture. Since we are weaker to compete financially with missionaries' millions of dollars in proselytising efforts in Nepal, the secularism doesn't do according to what you say as providing a free space to operate all the religions together. What happens in the long run is: we get uprooted, and our culture gets frozen in the histroy. Its good to allow all the religions but that is to seen in relative sense. Are we well enough to fund as do Christian missionaries now? Are our folks well-educated not to get influenced of their enticing offers while choosing their religion according to their self-will? These are the reasons I see come as hurdle in hurriedly declaring Nepal a secular state. In fact, I know that secularism is a form of democracy and it should be practised but in an ideal state where all the citizens are well educated and financially better off. I respect you guys' concern towards aloowing all religions a due place to operate their activities but the fundamental problem is of ideology:  they want proselytisation usiing all the measures: economic, diplomatic and many other state aparatuses but Hindus don't have such programs like proselytisation. You guys are well informed of the facts but lack a serious critical dimension on these issues: especially from the perspective of politics and ideology.

I expect some good thoughts than cheap rantings in this thread (such as Awatar. Grow up Awatar!. U sound like an offspring of Maoists' broken condom while having Comredly sex in the Jungle. I know what comrades say: Haami krantikari haru cheli sanga ratvari eutai ochhyaan ma sutchhau tara kehi gardainau.  Beef khana ta timra  ....le Rolpa ko jungle mai sikayeka holan ni. Jhan yaha aayera ta kina khadaina thhyau. Khau babu tehi khana ta aayeka holau. 

So you care only about your culture. How about mine, my neighbors and friends,  and those in different parts of Nepal.  Now comes financial problem re...No offense...but yesterday is history...lets build NAYA NEPAL.

"U sound like an offspring of Maoists' broken condom while having Comredly sex in the Jungle. I know what comrades say: Haami krantikari haru cheli sanga ratvari eutai ochhyaan ma sutchhau tara kehi gardainau.  Beef khana ta timra  ....le Rolpa ko jungle mai sikayeka holan ni."

--very funny btw I am not Maoist

BANAYO NAYA NEPAL.........GHANTO JASTO.............ITS A JOKE......NAYA NEPAL NAYA NEPAL BHANDAI BHAYEKO NEPAL LAI TUKRA TUKRA BANAISAKYO..........its a never ending trend............TOO MUCH HARM AND DESTRUCTION HAS ALREADY BEEN DONE TO CREATE THIS NAYA NEPAL.....IF THE MAOIST RULE THERE WILL BE ANOTHER ARMED CONFLICT AGAINST THE MAOIST LED GOVERNMENT....THIS WILL NEVER END........SALA NAYA NEPAL....GHANTA KO??

Yo naya Nepal bhanne jhuto rhetoric ho. Mao-Fuggarame-Jungali-Prachande ka dhal futera janmeka chhaura haru chyau chyau garchhan Naya Nepal, Naya Nepal bhanera. Oye kati jhut ko kheti garchhau uchhittiyeka bhurn haru ho.

Take not on what it says after 4.00 minutes.
<object width="425" height="355"><param name="movie" value="https://www.youtube.com/v/5z99QalHoKY&hl=en"></param><param name="wmode" value="transparent"></param><embed src="https://www.youtube.com/v/5z99QalHoKY&hl=en" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" wmode="transparent" width="425" height="355"></embed></object>

<object width="425" height="355"><param name="movie" value="https://www.youtube.com/v/5z99QalHoKY&hl=en&rel=0"></param><param name="wmode" value="transparent"></param><embed src="https://www.youtube.com/v/5z99QalHoKY&hl=en&rel=0" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" wmode="transparent" width="425" height="355"></embed></object>

sorry for multiple posts.

here is the link
http://youtube.com/watch?v=5z99QalHoKY

मैले पोस्ट गर्यो कि धागो नै सकिन्छ भन्या ।

What a gruesome video. I am so sorry to hear that some mo..fu Nepalis and their devil sponsors are working day and night to change religion of our folks. What a nasty guy with his  bitch like wife. Mo..fu Sudeep Khadka is proud to have his Kuhiyeko chak bhayeko khairi randika baan. Paisako lagi je pani garne thukka muji namarda khate. English futti navako, anuhar pani kuchiyeko goltin ko batta jasto, ajha Pastor re! Ajha 1 generation mai Nepal lai Christian country banaune re. Teri ma..k...ne randika baan Sudeep and teski chak kuhiyeki Khaireni. Timiharu lai chak ma tato suli le daamna napugeka bairi haru!

Now the Maoists have already said that they are removing all the Hindu and Buddhist traditional cultures of Nepal including "Kumari" relating them to have associated with the Monarchy. They are preparing to bring the situation of Tibet after Mao-tse-Tung and his cultural relvolution attempted to sweep away the identity of Tibet and Buddhism.

Let us all the Hindu and Buddhist of Nepal get united to fight against Maoists and save our culture and religion.

None of you shit heads sound like a religios or spiritual human being. No matter wt you believe in , geeta, kuran, bible, karma , all teaches humanity. i dont think any religion teaches bad mouthing another human being like you guys are diong. shame on you all.

Sarkozy, would you have appealed to fight against Maoists, if they had decided to remove just the churches and mosques?

One mystery about my own religion,

All god and goddess need to be king or queen???????

Indra King of Heaven

Shiva King of Kailash

Ram King of Ayodhaya

Krisna Belongs to Royal Family

Bishnu  who always reborn in royal family

Buddha Price of Lumbini.....................

Yes of course I would. Hindus have never removed Churches and Mosques which are in Nepal. Our only concern with the Christians is regarding their proselytizing drive. It is because we don't do that and if we allow them to do, ultimately we will be prone to get removed from our culture. That is only the concern with Christians and Muslims. If they don't practice proselytisation with the help of their millions of dollar, we are happy to live with them in Nepal. They can practice their religion as long as they don't snatch Hindus' traditional values with the Western and non-Sanatan Dharma culture.

Garibkochhora and Jhareko paat: you kids are still to grow and learn. Before showing up here with bullshit  arguments of non-sense meaning, please have some knowledge of how cultural politics is working in the world, and how much concerned are the Western countries towards their cultures and religion, despite having their  advancement on science and technology. Just don't make cheap remarks on the basis of your fuc--n aerial knowledge based on Fox and CNN news channel and You-Tube. Grow up guys. Have some orientation towards where you relate and just don't live in a hallucination of Western media, cultural products and education. Try to see things critically dudes.
Jaya Pashupatinaath!!

Hey, I am not for or against what the Maoists are doing. I don't even like the Maoists. And just because some disillusioned evangelists try to convert Nepalese people in return for financial help does not mean that all Nepalese Christians are like that. Most of us believe in peaceful coexistence.

In every religion, there are some people who give a wrong twist to the original religion. Take for example, the caste system in Hindu religion which was not an integral part of Hinduism in the beginning. People were divided into four classes (Varnas) in the Vedic era but that did not depend on the parentage but on what they did for a living. It was only later that sociopolitical change within the Hindu society made caste system into a hereditary thing.  In Christianity too we have a lot of zealots who give a distorted meaning to the teachings of the Bible. I don't believe in evangelism which has a sole purpose of converting people into Christianity. A true evangelist spreads love and understanding and caring equally among Christians and non-Christians without discrimination and without any expectations in return. When Jesus helped and healed he did not discriminate whether they were Jews, Romans or other people. He did not demand that they become his followers before he healed them. Islam does not teach to launch a war against the "infidels".

Having said that, we believe that a government and the state should not be affiliated to any particular religion. Even in a secular state of Nepal, Hindus and Buddhists will still be very dominant in the society. Nothing is going to change that. Just because Nepal becomes secular, Christmas and Id-ul-Fitr is not going to be bigger than Dashain and Buddha Jayanti. So, you need to see the bigger picture, have more faith in the strength of your own religion and stop feeling threatened by the minorities.